Thursday, August 23, 2018

Comments to Gail...


“Sex worker activists are savvy feminist analysts of ... machinations, their consciousness undoubtedly sharpened by daily trials of (escaping) state entrapment, extortion, imprisonment, and slander. As intimates of both back room and front stage men, prostitutes are solicited by government officials to serve as undercover agents and informants. ...Mainstream feminists would do well to listen to their word in public as male authorities do in private.
Their first demand is decriminalisation of sex work. This implies repealing prohibitions against negotiations and services attached to the sex industry, including the hiring of third parties to facilitate management of businesses and travel to foreign markets. In other words, sex workers demand the abolition of anti-prostitution, anti-pimping and anti-trafficking laws. They know that such laws invariably translate into discriminatory surveillance, fines, arrest, detention, and expulsion of migrant women. At long last, listen to the women! Gail Pheterson 2 Mar 2016 www.opendemocracy.net










I would like to address this final sentence from an article I found while researching 'Answers to a Red Life'*. I may return to other points in the article as they are interesting to consider.

If I am a mainstream feminist – I'm not sure I am. When I listen to most prostitutes and sex workers I can't see where they are striving for something that also supports my liberation

Where on the planet are migrant women allowed to travel freely? When prostitutes demand the right to travel freely are they arguing to obtain it for all women in all industries? Are they arguing and demanding it for all people, engaged in class struggles against the hegemony?

Laws, proposed, new and current in our judiciary are aimed at controlling, dis-empowering and subduing the masses, propping the elite and maintaining the systems of inequality. We are all ultimately battling the same monster, the same system.

When those fighting for their liberation invariably seem to set up little camps and spend all their energy on all the places where their definitions of liberty/liberation differ with each other, this only ensures the continuation of the need for liberation by allowing the current systems to continue.

Prostitutes and other sex workers want the raised remunerative rewards of their work; created by the fact that it operates outside of the law and they are demanding all the protections created in law for general workers rights.

Personally I find this contrary because our system requires that works carried out by (unskilled labourers) persons with little educational paperwork to show their investment in the system are unentitled to the same level of payment as those with qualifications. I know many prostitutes and strippers would call their work skilled and be that as it may, it's not really something one needs to study to do it adequately enough for the clients.

Legalised prostitution would surely therefore earn rates similar to those of other domestic workers. For is that not the place state and church say sex should occur? Child carers, service workers, cleaners home makers their low (lack of) payment regard and status are the roots of gendered womanhood that restrict the ability to create wealth. Prostitutes profit literally by their rejection of gendered labour being intrinsically badly paid because it is supposed to given freely. They also pay no tax. Though the vast majority say they would be happy to do so to gain employment protection.

I can't imagine any of them being prepared to accept the standard hourly rates of any other kind of gendered servicing work or fighting to have other women in those industries paid the same hourly rates as they are.

How about if all the women's liberationist organisations worldwide came together to focus on one goal; the complete eradication of patriarchy – which would probably necessitate the eradication of 1MG religions (Xtianity, Islam, Judaism, Zoroastrianism...?), capitalism, war?
It seems as if currently most liberationist movements just focus on worming their way into a better deal for themselves within the status quo. Just trying to get a couple of steps up the ladder

With no other choice (assuming they reject rape) many if not most men will/would pay for sex and they are willing to pay a lot more for that than they are for cleaning, cooking or child care. Can you imagine how quickly things could potentially change if prostitutes (and wives) went on an international strike for the pay rights of all women?

That would set them a place on the feminist agenda that would be impossible to not support and give them a chunky voice in recreating the world.